JUNE 30, 2026 by Lisa HARDING

Listen to our channel on...

Apple Music

#109: From Teacher to Nonprofit Managing Director

with Amber Shields

After spending 11 years in education, including roles as a kindergarten teacher, third grade teacher, instructional coach, and elementary principal–Amber Shields wasn't actively looking for a new job.

But one unexpected phone call from a former colleague changed everything.

Today, Amber serves as a Managing Director for a nonprofit organization, where she partners with school districts across her community to improve outcomes for children and families while enjoying greater balance, flexibility, and opportunities for professional growth.

In this insightful conversation, Teacher Career Transition Academy Career Coach Meagan Johnson sits down with Amber to discuss how networking opened the door to her career transition, why teachers have more transferable skills than they realize, and what hiring managers are truly looking for when educators apply for roles outside the classroom.

Together, they discuss:

  • How one professional connection led to an unexpected career opportunity
  • Why separating your identity from your job title is one of the hardest parts of leaving education
  • What a Managing Director in the nonprofit sector actually does
  • How teachers can better communicate their transferable skills during interviews
  • Why networking and LinkedIn are essential tools for career transition
  • What hiring managers look for when interviewing former educators
  • How to negotiate a job offer with confidence—and why it's about more than just salary
  • How her transition created more balance, flexibility, and capacity for both family and personal growth

Whether you're interested in nonprofit work or simply wondering what life after teaching could look like, this episode offers practical advice, honest encouragement, and a powerful reminder that the skills you've built in education can open doors to meaningful opportunities far beyond the classroom.

Links from Episode:


» Keep Learning With Me: Discover the Teacher Career Transition Academy

» Join our FB Group: A thriving community of support and resources.

» Download the Career Directory: Discover over 200+ alternative careers.

» “I love Lisa and the Teacher Career Transition Podcast” If this sounds like you, please consider rating and reviewing my show! This helps me support more people – just like you – find happiness in a new career. Click here, scroll to the bottom, tap to rate with five stars, and select “Write a Review”.

» Also, if you haven’t done so already, follow the podcast. I’m adding special surprises to the feed, and if you aren’t following, you have a good chance of missing out! Follow now!